Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant’s customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. By purchasing the products we rank, you’ll get the lowest price we found while we may receive a commission at no cost to you, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Best Choice 
Nefarious 
Village of Shadows Insane Publishing 
The Horror Files: A Sinister Collection of Supernatural Horror, Myths, Legends and Suspense Stories. Book 1 (The Horror 
The Amityville Horror Best Value Scare Street 
Coffin Cemetery: Supernatural Horror with Scary Ghosts & Haunted Houses (Tormented Souls Series Book 1) 
DOLLHOUSE: A Supernatural Horror (Dark Carousel Book 1) 
The Hollow Ones:: A Supernatural Horror Thriller of Forgotten Towns and Watching Eyes 14% Off Canelo The Fisherman: A chilling supernatural horror epic -
The Conjuring -
Insidious: The Red Door Wildside Press Supernatural Horror in Literature & Other Literary Essays Supernatural Horror In Literature & Other Literary EssaysRead & Co. Books Supernatural Horror in Literature: And Notes on Writing Weird Fiction Supernatural Horror In Literature: And Notes On Writing Weird Fiction-
The Conjuring 2 -
Case 39 -
The Witch -
Grave Encounters 2 -
The Nun II 22% Off Arcadia The Bewitching: folk horror meets dark academia in this thrilling supernatural mystery from the bestselling author of Me HarperCollins Supernatural: Nevermore: 1 Scare Street Worthe's Village: Supernatural Horror with Scary Ghosts & Haunted Houses (Haunted Village Series Book 1) Gutickodec 100 Pcs Horror Stickers,Horror Gifts,Horror Movie Stickers,Horror Decor,Scary Movie Gifts,Spooky Gifts,Supernatural Stic 【Premium & Value Stickers】These stickers are made of high-quality PVC material and exquisite craftsmanship, including 10-
The Autopsy of Jane Doe -
The Haunting In Connecticut -
The Blackwell Ghost -
The Taking of Deborah Logan Independently Published The Supernatural Horror Collection HarperCollins Supernatural: Witch's Canyon: 2 Scare Street Death's Mark: Supernatural Horror with Scary Ghosts & Haunted Houses: 1 -
Smile 34% Off Penguin American Supernatural Tales: Penguin Horror Series Penguin BooksScare Street Death's Mark: Supernatural Horror with Scary Ghosts & Haunted Houses: 1 -
Skinamarink 34% Off Penguin American Supernatural Tales: Penguin Horror Series Penguin Books-
Grave Encounters Running Press Adult Supernatural Oracle: A Hunter's Deck and Guidebook Velox Books With Teeth: Stories of Horror and the Supernatural -
Truth Or Dare - Extended Director's Cut -
The Uninvited 16% Off Poisoned Pen Press Hunted AP Publishers The Amityville Horror: True Story of the DeFeo Murders and Real Paranormal Event (Horror Stories That Grip You with Fear 16% Off Poisoned Pen Press Hunted -
The Uninvited 22% Off Bantam We Used to Live Here: The most chilling, gripping suspense thriller of 2024 that will leave you sleeping with the lights -
The Possession of Hannah Grace The Demonic: Book 1 in the Supernatural Horror Series (Supernatural Horror Novel Series) Insight Editions Supernatural: The Men of Letters Bestiary: Winchester Family Edition 13% Off Poisoned Pen Press From Below From Below-
The Sixth Sense Warner Home Video Supernatural: Season 14 (DVD) Prabhat Prakashan The Wendigo: Algernon Blackwood's Bone-Chilling Horror Story of the Supernatural (Best Classic Horror Novels of All Time Prabhat Prakashan The Wendigo: Algernon Blackwood's Bone-Chilling Horror Story of the Supernatural (Best Classic Horror Novels of All Time Pinstant Pinstant Supernatural TV Show Fantasy Horror Drama 17.7" Neck Lanyard Keychain Holder ID Badge Mobile Phone Pin Strap, B Celebrate your love of Supernatural with this ID badge keychain lanyard holder.Zenith Maple Leaf Press Supernatural Horror in Literature: A Definitive Study of Gothic Tales, Weird Fiction, and the Art of Terror 23% Off Simon & Schuster Jujutsu Kaisen, Vol. 18: Volume 18 Product Type - Abis Book-
Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter HarperVoyager The Book Eaters: The SUNDAY TIMES bestselling gothic fantasy horror, perfect for Halloween The Book Eaters: the SUNDAY TIMES bestselling gothic fantasy horror - a debut to sink your teeth intoFantasy Flight Games Arkham Horror: The Card Game – The Midwinter Gala: Scenario Pack) Players must collaborate to prevent apocalyptic outcomes23% Off Simon & Schuster Jujutsu Kaisen, Vol. 12: Volume 12 The Last Rite 15% Off LALAASHHOP Halloween Hanging Ghost, Horror Ghost Spooky Decorations, Decorative Halloween Haunted House Prop for Indoor Outdoor Dec SPOOKY DESIGN: Features a haunting ghost figure with flowing white fabric that creates an eerie, supernatural atmosphereSHOUT! FACTORY Golden Harvest, Volume 1: Supernatural Shockers Play Now Media LLLC Free Horror Movies Save favorites list31% Off DC Comics The Sandman Book One The Sandman 123% Off Tor UK The Atlas Six: The Atlas Six Book 1: the No.1 Bestseller and TikTok Sensation Product Type - Abis Book15% Off LALAASHHOP Halloween Hanging Ghost, Horror Ghost Spooky Decorations, Decorative Halloween Haunted House Prop for Indoor Outdoor Dec SPOOKY DESIGN: Features a haunting ghost figure with flowing white fabric that creates an eerie, supernatural atmospherePicador Lovecraft Country: TV Tie-In Lovecraft CountryFantasy Flight Games Asmodee North America Arkham Horror The Drowned City Investigator Expansion Living Card Game) Cooperative gameplay for 1-4 players, where teamwork is essential to survive23% Off Titan Books Horror Movie FieerWomen Cold Sanctuary (2) 22% Off Night Shade Books The Best Horror of the Year, Volume Sixteen Image Comics Creepshow, Volume 1 Creepshow, Volume 122% Off Simon & Schuster Classic Tales of Horror Peels4u Peels4u The Exorcist 1973 Cult Vintage Supernatural Horror Film Movie Poster Print A3 A4 (A3) Wall Art22% Off Gollancz The Green Mile: The iconic horror masterpiece NewGallery Books The Amityville Horror 29% Off DOUBLEDAY UK House Of Leaves: the prizewinning and terrifying cult classic that will turn everything you thought you knew about life Secrets of the Supernatural: Unravelling The Mysteries Beneath (The Haunting Horrors Series Book 4) Kiligry Tales from the Gas Station: Volume One Mini retro game console with built in games, no need for you to download any games, 821 games have been preset for you.23% Off Michael Joseph Gild: The TikTok fantasy sensation that's sold over half a million copies: 1 Gild: The dark fantasy TikTok sensation that’s sold over a million copies (Plated Prisoner, 1)46% Off sxdaizjsym sxdaizjsym 300 Pcs Horror Stickers,Horror Gifts,Horror Movie Stickers,Horror Decor,Scary Movie Gifts,Spooky Gifts,Supern 1.Package Includes: You will get 300 pieces Horror stickers and different designs. The quantity is enough to meet yourMVM Entertainment Pet Shop of Horrors RLJ Entertainment, Inc. Late Night With the Devil - Steelbook [4K UHD] Late Night With the Devil - Steelbook [4K UHD]Forest of the Damned: Book 3 in the Supernatural Horror Series (Supernatural Horror Novel Series) ZUIYIJIANGNAN 50Pcs Horror Gothic Stickers,Horror Gifts,Horror Girls Stickers,Horror Decor, Gifts,Spooky Skull Gifts,Supernatural Hall Horror Gothic Stickers: This sticker pack contains 50 different Cartoon stickers for Kids. All water bottle stickers areArrow Video J-Horror Rising Blu-ray Vengeful ghosts returning from beyond the grave, young women with supernatural abilities, investigative narratives, a tePOV Horror Free Found Footage Movies On-Demand Save favorites listMidnight Horrors: 20 Chilling Tales of the Supernatural, Short Stories with Shocking Twist Endings for Fans of Creepy Ta DC Comics American Vampire Omnibus Vol. 1 (2022 Edition) American Vampire Omnibus 115% Off Warner Bros The Conjuring Steelbook [4K Ultra HD] [2013] The ConjuringThe Mark: Book 2 in the Supernatural Horror Series (Supernatural Horror Novel Series) POV Horror Free Found Footage Movies On-Demand Save favorites listThe Mark: Book 2 in the Supernatural Horror Series (Supernatural Horror Novel Series) Tulade Tales from the Gas Station: Volume Four Mini retro game console with built in games, no need for you to download any games, 821 games have been preset for you.Poltergeists: 100 True Stories of Violent Ghost Activity (Horror & Supernatural) 24% Off Warner Bros The Conjuring 4K [4K Ultra HD] [2013] The Conjuring30% Off Spirit Entertainment Hammer House of Horror: The Complete Series Blu-Ray Hammer House of Horror: The Complete Series Blu-RayTulade Tales from the Gas Station: Volume Two Mini retro game console with built in games, no need for you to download any games, 821 games have been preset for you.David C. Cassidy 1944: A Gripping Supernatural Horror Thriller Zenith Ivory Tower Publications Supernatural Horror in Literature: H. P. Lovecraft's Definitive Guide to the Macabre and the Unknown Simon & Schuster Genesis: Get Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer game 1