Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant's customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. As an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive a commission from purchases made through links on our site, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Best Choice 
My Neighbor’s Brother: A Forbidden Neighbors-to-Lovers MM Gay Romance (Secrets Next Door Book 2) My Neighbor’s Brother: A Forbidden Neighbors-to-Lovers MM Gay Romance (Secrets Next Door Book 2) 
Hold Still For Me: A Funny Slow Burn Nerd/Jock MM Romance Hold Still For Me: A Funny Slow Burn Nerd/Jock MM Romance Best Value 
MY BOSS, MY FIRST: A Forbidden Straight to Gay First Time MM Romance MY BOSS, MY FIRST: A Forbidden Straight to Gay First Time MM Romance 
The One Who Stays: A Gay Best-Friends-to-Lovers Stepbrothers Romance The One Who Stays: A Gay Best-Friends-to-Lovers Stepbrothers Romance Audible Boyfriend Material Audible Boyfriend Material Sourcebooks Casablanca Promise Me (Sinful Manor Book 2) Sourcebooks Casablanca Promise Me (Sinful Manor Book 2) UwU Publishing The Kraken's Treasure: A Spicy Gay Pirate Shifter Monster Romance UwU Publishing The Kraken's Treasure: A Spicy Gay Pirate Shifter Monster Romance KA Books Voyageurs: Gay Romance Paint Our Song (Cloverlily Book 1) Paint Our Song (Cloverlily Book 1) Brave New Words Every Reason to Stay: A MM Small-Town Gay Second Chance Romance (Bears of Firefly Valley Book 3) Brave New Words Every Reason to Stay: A MM Small-Town Gay Second Chance Romance (Bears of Firefly Valley Book 3) Stay in Rio: The Soccer Star and the American Student (MM Romances by Elle Harlan) Stay in Rio: The Soccer Star and the American Student (MM Romances by Elle Harlan) Audible Without You Audible Without You All-Nighters (Ridgemont University Book 3) All-Nighters (Ridgemont University Book 3) THE ENFORCER'S BLINDSPOT: MM Dark Romance / Hockey / Omegaverse - The Ice Rivals, Book 1 THE ENFORCER'S BLINDSPOT: MM Dark Romance / Hockey / Omegaverse - The Ice Rivals, Book 1 KA Books Synchronicity: Gay Sports Romance Acerbi & Villani ltd. Bare-Knuckle Love (biker gay dark romance): Rabid Mongrels MC Steady Burn: MM Gay Cowboy Daddy Romance (Redmond Brothers Book 1) Steady Burn: MM Gay Cowboy Daddy Romance (Redmond Brothers Book 1) Knotting The Alpha: MM Gay Shifter MPREG Romance (The River Crash Book 1) Knotting The Alpha: MM Gay Shifter MPREG Romance (The River Crash Book 1) It Started with a Text: A Mistaken Identity MM Romantic Comedy Novella (Queer Ways to Fall in Love Book 2) It Started with a Text: A Mistaken Identity MM Romantic Comedy Novella (Queer Ways to Fall in Love Book 2) Gone Wild (Wild Hearts Book 1) Gone Wild (Wild Hearts Book 1) Cruz Publishing Making It Royal: A Royal MM Romance (The Making It Series) Anderson's Reinvention: A Love in Mission City Gay Romance Novella Anderson's Reinvention: A Love in Mission City Gay Romance Novella Septante, Nonante: A Marriage-of-Convenience MM Romance (70/90 Book 1) Rewriting Destiny (Ridgemont University Book 4) Rewriting Destiny (Ridgemont University Book 4) Leta Blake Books White Heat: a Heat of Love novella PLPublishing Unforgettable Encounter: A short, free Kindle M/M billionaire romance—seductive, heartfelt, and slow-burning (A Power an Rainbow Tree Publishing Realigned: A M/M Small-Town Romance (Coming Home) Off Limits: My Best Friend’s Brother: A Forbidden MM Gay Romance with Best Friend’s Brother, Slow Burn & Secret Relation Off Limits: My Best Friend’s Brother: A Forbidden MM Gay Romance with Best Friend’s Brother, Slow Burn & Secret Relation Embrace of Shadows: M/M Gay Vampire MPREG Romance Embrace of Shadows: M/M Gay Vampire MPREG Romance Newton's Laws of Attraction (The Science of Love Book 1) Newton's Laws of Attraction (The Science of Love Book 1) Fierce Hold: MM Gay Cowboy Daddy Romance (Redmond Brothers Book 4) Fierce Hold: MM Gay Cowboy Daddy Romance (Redmond Brothers Book 4) Scribble Pretty Books Wolfseeker (Wolfseeker Trilogy Book 1) Scribble Pretty Books Wolfseeker (Wolfseeker Trilogy Book 1) Hot Hot Heat: Nico & Carter: MM Straight-to-Gay Omegaverse Hot Hot Heat: Nico & Carter: MM Straight-to-Gay Omegaverse Corporate Rivals: His Personal Intern: An MM Age-Gap Billionaire BDSM Romance Featuring an Older Dominant CEO and His Ga Corporate Rivals: His Personal Intern: An MM Age-Gap Billionaire BDSM Romance Featuring an Older Dominant CEO and His Ga Storm Publishing The Kennedy Rule: An addictive rivals-to-lovers MM hockey romance (On Thin Ice Book 1) Storm Publishing The Kennedy Rule: An addictive rivals-to-lovers MM hockey romance (On Thin Ice Book 1) Offside Hearts: A Steamy Forbidden MM Gay Football Romance (Teammates, Closeted, Age Gap, Sports Romance) (Offside Heart Offside Hearts: A Steamy Forbidden MM Gay Football Romance (Teammates, Closeted, Age Gap, Sports Romance) (Offside Heart 25% Off Michael Joseph Teacher of the Year: A Feel-Good LGBTQ+ Romance About Love, Lessons, and Starting Over Michael Joseph Teacher of the Year: A Feel-Good LGBTQ+ Romance About Love, Lessons, and Starting Over 36% Off RANDOM HOUSE UK Hunt the Villain: A binge-worthy dark college romance from the New York Times bestselling author The Man Who Raised Me: A Forbidden MM Gay Age Gap Guardian Romance (Forbidden Bonds Series) The Man Who Raised Me: A Forbidden MM Gay Age Gap Guardian Romance (Forbidden Bonds Series) Tuxbury Publishing LLC My Kind of Guy (Hockey Guys: a series of MM stand-alone novels Book 4) RE/STRUNG: Straight to Gay MM First Time Pianist: A Dark Anonymous Club Romance (The Back Room Book 9) RE/STRUNG: Straight to Gay MM First Time Pianist: A Dark Anonymous Club Romance (The Back Room Book 9) Hold Fast: A Gay Sports Romance Hold Fast: A Gay Sports Romance Straight Best Friend: Straight to Gay MM First Time Erotica (Gay Encounters Collection Book 2) Straight Best Friend: Straight to Gay MM First Time Erotica (Gay Encounters Collection Book 2) Proud Marlee Press Much Obliged: A British Fake Dating Romantic Comedy Set on a Reality Dating Show (The Brent Boys Book 3) Drilled By My Bodyguard: Straight to Gay MM First Time Dark Erotic Romance (Straight to Gay: Urban Tales Book 10) Drilled By My Bodyguard: Straight to Gay MM First Time Dark Erotic Romance (Straight to Gay: Urban Tales Book 10) Sinner's Haven Publishing Kiss Your Scars: A Dark Enemies-to-Lovers Gay Romance (Loose Ends Book 4) Sinner's Haven Publishing Kiss Your Scars: A Dark Enemies-to-Lovers Gay Romance (Loose Ends Book 4) This Guy : MM Small-Town Romance (Wood Hollow Stories Book 1) This Guy : MM Small-Town Romance (Wood Hollow Stories Book 1) JMS Books LLC 2025 Top Ten Gay Romance JMS Books LLC 2025 Top Ten Gay Romance KA Books The Station: Gay Romance KA Books The Station: Gay Romance Good Man Press The Ultimate Save: A Gay Hockey Romance (Brooklyn Blades Book 2) The Boy Who Taught Me to Live: An Emotional MM Gay Hospital Cancer Romance (Borrowed Time Romance) The Boy Who Taught Me to Live: An Emotional MM Gay Hospital Cancer Romance (Borrowed Time Romance) Blue Rain Press Jack Be Nimble: A Gay MM Small Town Romance (Boxcar Boys Book 1) Blue Rain Press Jack Be Nimble: A Gay MM Small Town Romance (Boxcar Boys Book 1) Big Wolf Falling: Gay Werewolf Shifter Romance (Blood Brothers Pack Book 1) Big Wolf Falling: Gay Werewolf Shifter Romance (Blood Brothers Pack Book 1) UwU Publishing Alpha's Awakening: Gay Wolf Shifter Romance (Tales of the Tellurian Pack Book 1) UwU Publishing Alpha's Awakening: Gay Wolf Shifter Romance (Tales of the Tellurian Pack Book 1) Men Turned Gay Bundle: 17 Story Straight to Gay First Time MM and MMM Anthology Collection (MM Straight to Gay First Tim Men Turned Gay Bundle: 17 Story Straight to Gay First Time MM and MMM Anthology Collection (MM Straight to Gay First Tim His Wicked Alpha: A MM Boss/Employee, Opposites Attract, Forced Proximity Omegaverse Romance (Messy Ever After Book 3) His Wicked Alpha: A MM Boss/Employee, Opposites Attract, Forced Proximity Omegaverse Romance (Messy Ever After Book 3)